As a huge Sorkin fan, I was sad to see the West Wing go, but happy to learn that Bradley Whitford would be back in the fall on a Sorkin vehicle. So I was on the couch, glued to the TV for last night's debut.
First it was interesting to see what were the Bradley Whitford mannerisms as opposed to the character of Josh Lyman from the West Wing. From the hands in the pockets to the way he sits down, to the head angle when talking, there were a few moments when it seemed Josh Lyman was going to break through. I also thought Matthew Perry did a pretty good job (I liked the bit about Pat Robertson).
Amanda Peet on the other hand, needed to stop looking like a kid in a candy store. The twinkle in her eye in every scene seemed too fake, too wide-eyed for someone who had been in the business. She didn't deliver her lines well in the emergency meeting after Judd Hirsch went off in the opening scene.
Finally, the lighting of the show needs some serious work. On a HDTV, the whole thing seemed too dark - it was difficult to pick out certain characters....
On the whole, it wasn't the greatest of premieres, but it didn't fall flat on its face.